Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison between majority expert opinions and questionnaire scoring systems

From: Identification of adults with symptoms suggestive of obstructive airways disease: Validation of a postal respiratory questionnaire

 

Categories of score

"Meriting a trial of medication"

"Not meriting a trial of medication"

Total

 

All responses

116

85

201*

System 1

Four or more symptoms/risk factors

109

37

146

 

Fewer than four or more symptoms/risk factors

7

48

55

System 2

Four or more symptoms/risk factors plus one marker of severity

100

22

122

 

Other responses-

16

63

79

  1. * One subject was not categorised by one of the consultants and the other two disagreed on the decision on whether a trial of obstructive airways disease treatment was indicated so no majority decision could be made. This individual was excluded from analysis.